Baywatch is the latest attempt at adapting a serious series into a comedy, and stars Dwayne Johnson and Zac Efron as members of the titular lifeguard team.
Baywatch is not the worst comedy I've seen this year, it is also not the best. It's a very average comedy. Yes there are some scenes which are laugh out loud funny, but there are also several scenes of silence.
Dwayne Johnson is a very likeable guy. Like Tom Hanks, it would be very interesting to see him as a villain. However, here he is Lieutenant(?) Mitch Buchannon, head lifeguard. Of course he's likeable, yes he's funny, but the material let's him down somewhat. The best parts are when he's interacting with Zac Efron's trainee lifeguard Matt Brody, who is also a disgraced Olympic athlete. It is fun to see them interact with each other and there is a good running joke where Johnson refers to him as several popular young musicians. The rest of the cast don't have much to do. But Jon Bass, who I have not seen in anything else, does the best with what he's given. Yes, he is basically playing the funny, nerdy, fat guy, but he fully embraces it.
The writing is not very smart, and there are some jokes that sound like they are ripped straight from a conversation between a group of 13 year olds at school. Baywatch is trying to Jump Street the franchise, but when there are very few smart jokes, it's not going to succeed. The Jump Street films were funny because they poked fun at themselves and the show, pointing out how ridiculous many things were. This year, both this and Chips(which I purposefully avoided) have tried to replicate what was so good about the Jump Street films, but from what I gather neither understands why they were two of the most intelligent, and funniest, comedies of the last few years. The Jump Street films were self aware and never took themselves seriously. They were meta, self aware, embraced their ridiculousness while also questioning it at every corner. Baywatch thinks that what made them successful was adapting a cheesy show from 25 years ago and making it a raunchy r-rated comedy. It's because of this that Baywatch is not able to go anywhere near the heights of Jump Street.
I like a bit of realism in comedies. Absurdism is fine, but I like a few moments where a character points out the absurdism. There are a few moments when Efron reminds Johnson that they are lifeguards and not cops, but when the bland corruption story starts to unravel and the ridiculousness increases, I would have liked for a character to realise this and point this out. Throughout the film people die, and towards the end the lifeguards definetely kill some people, yet we never see any consequences for their actions. The only consequence is a temporary firing from the watch.
In short: Baywatch has its moments, but is mostly a waste of potential.