The Cloverfield Paradox is a colossal disappointment.
I am a fan of the Cloverfield franchise. The original is an excellent deconstruction of a genre which takes a unique, grounded viewpoint on an event which would usually be portrayed as huge, epic, and bombastic. Then 10 Cloverfield Lane expanded the franchise into interesting territory by making an indirect, barely connected sequel that stands on its own as an excellent claustrophobic thriller. It set up the franchise as a loosely connected anthology series which could explore completely different areas of sci-fi with a few similar themes and visual ideas. But, then The Cloverfield Paradox was released to the world...
Before I get onto the actual film, I have to give props to Netflix, and a hard stare to Paramount. Firstly, it was a bold decision by Netflix to just drop this film a few hours after the trailer was revealed. And, it was an extremely smart move to release the trailer during the Super Bowl. To my knowledge, Netflix have never done this sort of thing before (their original release plan for The Punisher was to do a surprise drop after the New York Comic Con panel had finished, but due to unforeseen events, they had to cancel that) and are truly industry trailblazers for pulling it off as well as they did.
But Paramount are a bunch of cotten-headed ninny muggins. They had a film which was part of a successful, proven franchise. But saw that it didn't quite work, and instead of giving notes to the director and requesting (more) reshoots, they decided that because franchise spearheader JJ Abrams wasn't available, they would accept mediocrity in the film and dump it in Netflix's hands for instant profit. I didn't have this viewpoint before I watched the film, it was only after I viewed the finished product and did some reading that I gained this perspective.
Before I watched the film, I presumed that Paramount had sold the distribution rights to Netflix as part of their attack on original sci-fi. I say "attack", but that's hyperbole. Recently, Netflix acquired the distribution rights to Annihilation, the new film by Alex Garland, for everywhere apart from USA, Canada and China. Because apparently, the head of Paramount thought the ending was too smart for audiences, and would have to be changed if his company were going to release it. Garland and a producer objected and fought back, eventually agreeing to have the film go straight to streaming services in every country which isn't a major North American country. I personally don't understand this decision; as hard sci-fi has not done well in USA in recent years, while it has performed better in other countries, such as the UK.
And I've not even got onto the insulting part to streaming services. After the divisive responses to mother! and Downsizing - mixed with disappointing box office returns - Paramount has seemingly decided that having their name attached to good, safe projects is better than continuing to release challenging films. And they relegate those underwhelming or potentially divisive films to Netflix, essentially using it as a dumping ground for their unwanted content. To be fair, Paramount aren't the first studio to do this. After shuffling around the release for a while, Universal gave Netflix distribution rights to Spectral (which I can't comment on the quality of) and have recently done something similar with Extinction. The problem is not just with Paramount, but they're who I'm angry with right now.
Anyway, onto the actual film. I watched it as soon as I possibly could, and by the time it was finished, I was extremely disappointed.
The first of my problems comes from how much of a mess the structure of the film is. There are so many ideas which are thrown out there, forgotten about, then briefly brought back up again later. And some of these ideas are very ill thought out and make little to no sense within the story. And they keep using the excuse of "alternate realities" as a scapegoat.
One of these ideas that actually plays a part in the story has to do with Chris O'Dowd's arm. I suspect this was concieved as being slightly humorous, but I found the execution to be so poor, that everything involving his arm I found unintentially hilarious. There is also a fairly major plot point involving his arm that shouldn't have happened logically. And I still don't understand how his arm operated.
There are many things like that, where they are novel ideas, but are executed without thought.